Middletown Fish Market — Facts & FAQs

1. What makes Middletown Fish Market different from other Retailers?

We focus exclusively on seafood — it’s our specialty, not just an aisle. Our fish and shellfish arrive fresh daily from trusted docks, and our team has decades of hands-on seafood expertise. With us, you’ll always know where your seafood comes from and how to prepare it.

2. Where are you located, and what are your hours?

You’ll find us in Union Square, Rt 35 South, Middletown, NJ — just minutes from Red Bank and easily accessible from surrounding Monmouth County neighborhoods.

We’re open daily from 12:00 - 6:00pm, with fresh deliveries arriving each morning.

3. What kind of seafood do you carry daily?

Our selection changes with the catch, but you’ll usually find:

  • Fresh Fish Fillets and Whole Fish (Bronzino, Cod, Flounder, Salmon, Tuna, etc.)

  • Clams, Mussels, Oysters, Scallops

  • Lobster and Crab (seasonal availability)

  • Shrimp (Cooked and Uncooked)

  • In Season Products

  • Specialty items brought in on request

4. Is your seafood local?

Whenever possible, we buy from local docks in New Jersey and the Northeast, supplemented by trusted global sources to ensure year-round freshness and variety.

5. How does your pricing work?

Because we receive daily deliveries, our prices reflect the freshest catches available. Seafood is seasonal, and costs can shift depending on the market — but you can always count on us to stay competitively priced while maintaining the highest standards of freshness and quality.

6. Do you sell cooked food or only raw seafood?

We are a retail seafood market — not a restaurant — but we do offer grab & go dishes made fresh in small batches throughout the day. These are perfect for quick meals without compromising quality.

In addition to seafood, we also carry homemade sauces, bottled and packaged specialty goods, caviar, and more to complement your meal.

7. Can I place a special order?

Yes! We can source almost any seafood item with next-day availability. Whether it’s a family dinner, a special event, or a favorite hard-to-find fish, let us know and we’ll bring it in for you.

8. Do you offer catering or large party trays?

We can prepare large seafood platters or bulk orders for parties, holidays, and gatherings. Call ahead and we’ll work with you to create the right selection for your table.

9. How do I know what’s fresh today?

The best way is to stop by the market or give us a call. Our staff will be happy to tell you what’s just arrived and even offer preparation tips.

10. Do you give cooking advice?

Absolutely. Our team is here to answer questions about cooking methods, recipes, and pairings. Whether you’re a seasoned home chef or cooking fish for the first time, we’ll guide you.

11. Do you offer delivery?

Right now, we focus on in-store pickup. However, we’re exploring partnerships for local delivery in the future.

12. What’s the ethos of Middletown Fish Market?

We’re built on three values: Freshness, Quality, and Community.

  • Freshness: Seafood is delivered daily so you can bring the best to your table.

  • Quality: Every product meets a standard we’d be proud to serve our own families.

  • Community: We’re more than a market — we’re neighbors serving neighbors, continuing a local tradition of trust and care.